How to Mix a Why Not: The Only Recipe You'll Ever Need

How to Mix a Why Not: The Only Recipe You'll Ever Need

Calendar Icon February 26, 2025 User Icon by BarBot Team

Introduction

The Why Not cocktail is a delightful creation that brings together the warmth of bourbon with the citrusy zest of Cointreau, the tang of fresh lemon juice, and the rich sweetness of maple syrup. It's a drink that invites curiosity and rewards the adventurous with its layered flavors and aromatic profile. This cocktail is perfect for those who appreciate the nuances of whiskey but are looking to explore something a little different.

The origins of the Why Not cocktail are shrouded in mystery, much like its intriguing name. Some say it was born out of a bartender's desire to experiment with flavors that complement the deep notes of bourbon. Regardless of its beginnings, the Why Not has become a beloved choice for cocktail enthusiasts seeking a unique and satisfying drink.

Interesting fact: The use of maple syrup in cocktails has gained popularity in recent years, adding depth and complexity to traditional recipes. In the Why Not, it serves as a sweet counterpoint to the tartness of lemon juice, creating a harmonious blend that pleases the palate.

Ingredients

  • 1.75 oz Black Label Bourbon
  • 0.5 oz Cointreau
  • 0.75 oz Fresh Lemon Juice
  • 0.5 oz Dark, Robust Maple Syrup
  • 1 Evan Williams Black Label Bourbon

To create the perfect Why Not cocktail, you'll need a selection of quality ingredients. Here's what you'll need to gather:

  • 1.75 oz Black Label Bourbon: Black Label Bourbon offers a smooth, rich foundation with notes of caramel and vanilla.
  • 0.5 oz Cointreau: Cointreau adds a bright, orange-flavored liqueur that enhances the cocktail's aromatic profile.
  • 0.75 oz Fresh Lemon Juice: Freshly squeezed lemon juice is essential for a crisp, tangy flavor that balances the sweetness.
  • 0.5 oz Dark, Robust Maple Syrup: Choose a dark, robust maple syrup for its rich, earthy sweetness that complements the bourbon.
  • 1 Evan Williams Black Label Bourbon: Evan Williams Black Label Bourbon is recommended for its bold character and smooth finish.

Instructions

Crafting a Why Not cocktail is a straightforward process that yields impressive results. Follow these steps to achieve cocktail perfection:

  1. Shake all the ingredients with ice.
  2. Strain into a double Old-Fashioned glass filled with ice.

Tips

  • Use a high-quality bourbon to ensure a smooth and flavorful base for your cocktail.
  • Chill your glass in the freezer before serving to keep the drink refreshingly cold.
  • Adjust the amount of maple syrup to taste, depending on your sweetness preference.
  • For an extra touch of sophistication, garnish with a twist of lemon peel or a sprig of fresh rosemary.

Conclusion

The Why Not cocktail is a testament to the art of mixology, blending classic ingredients in a way that feels both familiar and novel. Its rich, aromatic flavors make it a standout choice for any occasion, whether you're enjoying a quiet evening at home or entertaining guests.

Ready to explore more unique cocktails like the Why Not? Download the BarBot app today and dive into a world of endless cocktail possibilities. With BarBot, you can discover new recipes, log your tasting experiences, and even share your creations with a community of fellow cocktail enthusiasts. Elevate your home bartending skills and turn every sip into a memorable experience. Cheers to new adventures in flavor!

Why Not recipe adapted from Cocktail Codex by Alex Day.